Grilled to Perfection: Easy BBQ Oysters

BBQ oysters are a deliciously sweet and briny treat, with a crispy texture that’s perfect for summertime dining. Whether you’re a seafood lover or just looking to add some variety to your barbecue menu, these are sure to be a hit.

Fresh Butter Garlic BBQ Oysters in the shell make an amazing appetizer or entree for a lunch or seafood dinner. This recipe is perfect to enjoy with our Cheesy Bruschetta Garlic Bread, and Lemon Vinaigrette Quinoa Salad.

We will be showing you how to bbq oysters on the half shell (or whole shell) for a beautifully smoky essence that is delicious with a fresh garlic herbed butter sauce. Learning how to bbq oysters in the shell is very easy and yields delicious hot steamed oysters, ready to be dressed with your favorite sauce.

BBQ Oysters in the whole Shell

Okay, first off, can you grill oysters without shucking? Yes, oysters can be grilled in shell. Grilling the oysters while fully encased in their shell will steam them, retaining moisture and flavor and allowing them to be easily shucked.

Cooking oysters with the top shell on causes them to retain more moisture which can affect the texture and taste of the oyster.

1. Retains the natural juices: The oyster’s shell protects the meat from drying out, which helps it retain its natural juices. This results in a plumper and more flavorful oyster.
2. Keeps them stable: When grilling oysters, they can be a bit slippery, so having them in the shell helps to keep them stable on the grill grates.
3. Easy to handle: Grilled oysters on the half-shell are easy to handle and eat, they can be eaten directly from the shell with a fork or an oyster fork.
4. Adds flavor: Grilling oysters in the shell allows you to add butter, herbs, or other seasonings directly to the oyster, which infuses the meat with extra flavor.
5. Adds a rustic touch: Grilled oysters in the shell adds a rustic and natural touch to the presentation, making it more attractive and appealing to the eye.
6. Safety: Keeping oysters in their shells when grilling them is a safe way to cook oysters, as the shell protects the meat from any direct contact with the heat and prevents the oyster from spilling its juice.

Once the oysters open during cooking, the meat can be accessed more easily. However, some people prefer to remove the top shell before grilling so that they can add seasonings or toppings directly to the oyster meat during grilling.

Preparing BBQ Oysters in the shell for the grill

Preparing oysters without shucking them can be a bit tricky and requires some extra preparation steps. If you don’t shuck the oysters before grilling, the heat will cause the oyster to open on its own. If the oyster is not cleaned properly, it can result in sand or debris getting into the meat, which can be unpleasant to eat.

Here are some steps to prepare and grill oysters in the shell

1. Scrub the oysters: Scrub the oysters well with a stiff brush and cold water to remove any dirt or debris from the shells.
2. Purge the oysters: To remove any sand or grit, place the oysters in a bowl of cold water and let them sit for 30 minutes to an hour. This will allow the oysters to expel any sand or debris.
3. Clean the oysters: Once the oysters have purged, give them a final rinse under cold water and carefully remove any remaining debris from the shells.
4. Keep the oysters in the shell: Place the oysters on the grill with the flat side down, and the cupped side up.
5. Grill them: Grill the oysters for about 5-7 minutes or until the shells open. Be careful not to overcook them, as the oysters will become tough and rubbery.
6. Serve them: Once the oysters are done, remove them from the grill and serve them immediately. Make sure to use an oyster knife or a towel to protect your hand while opening the oysters, and be aware that the oyster liquor and steam may be hot.

Do oysters open on the BBQ? Yes cook them until they open. If the oyster doesn’t open during cooking it’s not safe to eat because it’s not fully cooked.

Consuming raw or undercooked oysters may increase your risk of foodborne illness, so it’s always a good idea to check the oyster’s quality and to make sure they are safe to eat before consuming them. If you’re not confident in your ability to prepare oysters safely, it’s best to shuck them prior to grilling.

Wondering how long to grill oysters in shell? This will depend on the size of the oysters as well as the grill used. A charcoal grill will steam oysters in as little as 7 minutes, while small portable propane grills can take up to 20 minutes. Oysters in the shell are done when the shells begin to open.

How do you know when oysters are ready on the grill? To know when oysters are ready on the grill, you can look for several signs:

1. Steam: When the oysters start to steam and the edges start to curl, it’s a good sign that they are ready to come off the grill.
2. Opened Shells: Another sign that oysters are ready is when the shells open. This means the heat has caused the oysters to contract, forcing the shells to open.
3. Time: On average, it takes about 3 to 5 minutes for oysters to cook on the grill, depending on their size and heat source.

If you grill oysters for too long, they get tough and lose their natural flavor. Keep a close eye on the grilled oysters as they cook. Remove them from the heat as soon as they are ready.

BBQ Oysters can be served in a variety of ways. This recipe is very simple and straightforward but can definitely be dressed up with a fancier sauce.

For example, you can turn this recipe into Grilled oysters Rockefeller by making the sauce for it. Rockefeller oyster sauce uses spices and herbs like paprika, parsley, and anise. These are bold flavors that compliment this seafood wonderfully. Also, White wine based butters like this one are always a popular choice in the world of shellfish cuisine.

We give you a recipe for the Rockefeller butter sauce in the notes section of our printable recipe care below.

Making BBQ Oysters on the Half Shell:

Shucking Oysters is an easy process. Shucking raw oysters is more difficult since the shell will resist open opening more when the oyster is completely raw.

It’s simpler to set the oysters on a hot grill and remove when the shells pop open slightly. Using a pairing knife gently open the shells and scrape the steamed oyster out of the shell.

A small pairing knife will help to twist open the shell. Heavy Gloves are recommended to protect your hands from the heat. However, grilled oysters will open much easier than raw oysters.

Shucking a cooked oyster that’s served on the half shell is a bit different than shucking a raw oyster. Here’s one method you can follow:

1. Hold the oyster with a towel or glove to protect your hand from the heat.
2. Insert an oyster knife or a small, sharp knife into the hinge of the oyster, where the top and bottom shells meet.
3. Twist the knife to break the hinge and open the oyster.
4. Run the knife along the top of the oyster to detach the meat from the top shell. Be careful not to lose any of the juices, which are known as the “liquor.”
5. Discard the top shell and serve the oyster on the bottom shell.

Shucking cooked oysters can be dangerous if you’re not experienced. The oysters should be opened when they’re still hot since this is easier then opening raw oysters. Wear heavy leather gloves to avoid the risk of getting burned.

Recent Posts:

• How to Cook the Perfect Blackstone Steak
• How to Make Rich and Creamy Chocolate Syrup at Home
• Easy Goat Cheese Appetizer with Cranberries and Pistachios
• Best Ever Pecan Pie Bars Recipe
• Best Pumpkin Cookes with Cheesecake Filling