Skip to Content

Chocolate Pudding Pie

Nothing compares to a  rich, thick, homemade Chocolate Pudding Pie. Even the pudding is made from scratch. Excellent quality no-bake dessert you make to your own taste. This is SO good!

I’m VERY excited about this pie! The thing is, I NEVER make pudding desserts. The packaged stuff tastes off to me and it’s all full of sugar and yucky stuff. So I usually just skip it. I never learned how to make my own pudding and just wrote it off. Who needs the extra calories right? Not that great anyway…until now!

Chocolate Pudding Pie

I found a recipe for homemade ‘from scratch’ chocolate pudding at Bunny’s Warm Oven. If you have read this blog for awhile you’ll know it’s not the first time Bunny has taught me a few things about baking. I strongly suggest you hop on over to her site for a great tutorial on this chocolate pudding process. If you’ve never made it before…she can help!

Chocolate Pudding PieI’m hitting the highlights here but Bunny’s tutorial is worth reading! I followed Bunny’s instructions exactly and this pudding turned out great. I love the firm consistency and, most of all, the flavor. What a great pie filling! Homemade pudding is a brand new flavor dimension if you’ve never had it. I was beyond impressed with the beautiful, clean, not too sweet or cloying, pudding flavor. The boxed stuff tastes like sweet goopy, chemicals to me. This homemade recipe shows off the chocolate in a rich thick pudding meant to be savored. I love it!Chocolate Pudding Pie


YOU WILL NEED TO DOUBLE THIS RECIPE FOR A NINE OR TEN INCH PIE! This recipe will do a small 8 inch pie crust and filling.

Chocolate Pudding Pie Entirely From Scratch. Amazing Flavor And So Easy! Make Ahead, No Bake Dessert! Http://

Chocolate Pudding Pie entirely from scratch. Amazing flavor and SO easy! Make ahead, no bake dessert!

A BIG THING about making this recipe! Do NOT do what I always like to do and turn it on high and walk away! NO, nononono! Bunny is VERY clear that the heat on your stove should be low from start to finish. No cheating or you WILL ruin it. To properly thicken this pudding you must Follow the directions. This recipe will make a lovely thick pudding or pie filling. I am thinking up all sorts of lovely recipes I can concoct with this yummy chocolate   pudding!With this pie crust and filling you will NOT need to turn on your oven. At All. We have a no bake dessert here. A press in crust that sets up in the fridge, just like the filling.

I use coconut oil in my crust and it sets up really well in the fridge. Coconut oil gets very firm at fridge temperatures. I have made this crust several times and when the dessert is properly cooled to fridge temperature the crust will firm up and stay firm, even at room temperature; And taste wonderful, and be full of GOOD fat!

I used coconut oil in the pudding as well. I love to cook with it and bake with it, and so much more! You can use butter, if coconut oil is not your thing. But I highly recommend a good quality, organic, virgin coconut oil become part of your cooking staples. It’s really healthy and really good to use in so many ways.Chocolate Pudding Pie Entirely From Scratch. Amazing Flavor And So Easy! Make Ahead, No Bake Dessert! Http://Homemadefoodjunkie.comI hope you won’t glop a big bunch of cool whip (my brother LOVES cool whip!), or other chemical laden whipped topping, on this beautiful pie. After the chocolate pudding pie is set I HOPE, you will actually pour about 2 cups of heavy whipping cream into a deep bowl and whip it up with a tablespoon or so of sugar (to taste) and maybe 1 tsp. of vanilla (to taste).

Whip it up until it gets firm and lather it on the top of the pie, pretty it up with a decorator tip, or set the whipped cream in a bowl with a spoon and let people dollop it on their pie as they like.

I enjoy a garnish of shaved dark chocolate on the top. It’s your pie, maybe you prefer a cherry, or drizzled chocolate sauce! Whatever you do, enjoy this delicious chocolate treat. It’s SO worth the extra work, I know you will love it.

Chocolate Pudding Pie:

Chocolate Pudding Pie

Chocolate Pudding Pie
Yield: 8 servings

Chocolate Pudding Pie

Prep Time: 1 hour
Additional Time: 2 hours
Total Time: 3 hours

Nothing compares to a  rich, thick, homemade Chocolate Pudding Pie. Even the pudding is made from scratch. Excellent quality no-bake dessert you make to your own taste.


  • 2/3 Cup sugar
  • 1/4 Cup cocoa
  • 3 Tablespoons cornstarch
  • 1/4 tsp. salt
  • 2 1/4 Cups milk
  • 2 Tablespoons butter
  • 1 tsp. vanilla extract
  • 10 graham crackers
  • 1/4 Cup walnuts
  • 1/4 Cup coconut oil, melted
  • 1/2 tsp. vanilla extract
  • Whipping cream, for garnish
  • shaved chocolate, for garnish


  1. Oil an eight inch pie plate and set aside

Making the crust:

  1. Make the crust by crumbling the graham cracker in your food processor. Add the nuts and process until small even pieces are distributed throughout the graham fines. Add the oil in through the top of the processor and pulse until the mixture is wet and crumbly
  2. Press the crust into your oiled pie plate. Set aside

Now make the filling and assemble:

  1. Keep the properly measured amount of oil and vanilla by the stove
  2. In a medium bowl whisk the cocoa powder, cornstarch and salt until all the lumps are out
  3. In a heavy sauce pan on LOW heat on your stove, place the sugar and whisked dry ingredients
  4. Whisk the milk slowly into the dry ingredients
  5. Now SLOWLY whisk this mixture until it becomes thick. This takes about 10 or 15 minutes
  6. The chocolate mixture will become thick quickly at the end and then slowly start to boil
  7. Let the mixture boil at a low heat for one minute
  8. Remove from heat and whisk in the oil and vanilla
  9. Pour immediately into your pie crust
  10. Cover the filling with plastic wrap RIGHT ON THE PUDDING
  11. Chill about two hours
  12. Decorate with whipped cream and shaved chocolate

Nutrition Information



Serving Size


Amount Per Serving Calories 329Total Fat 17gSaturated Fat 10gTrans Fat 0gUnsaturated Fat 6gCholesterol 18mgSodium 220mgCarbohydrates 40gFiber 1gSugar 22gProtein 5g

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

The Best Scratch Made Chocolate Pudding Pie-Pin Image

Nothing compares to a rich, thick, homemade Chocolate Pudding Pie. Even the pudding is made from scratch. Excellent quality no-bake dessert you make to your own taste.

Pin it:


Monday 13th of July 2015

This pie has my name written all over it!


Monday 13th of July 2015

Yes it does Katerina!

Joy @ Joy Love Food

Saturday 11th of July 2015

What a gorgeous pie, perfect for a hot summer day, yum!


Saturday 11th of July 2015

Thank you Joy


Friday 10th of July 2015

What a pretty pie you made! I agree with you about making homemade pudding and whipped cream. I just think they taste better!


Saturday 11th of July 2015

They really do Lydia

Betsy @ Desserts Required

Friday 10th of July 2015

BEYOND GORGEOUS!! I love every part of this pie and the ease in which it is made. KUDOS!


Friday 10th of July 2015

Thank you Betsy

Heidy L. McCallum

Friday 10th of July 2015

My grandmother used to make a chocolate pudding pie to die for, I haven't had one in years, so this baby is getting made ASAP!


Friday 10th of July 2015

Yay! I know this is SO retro! But it is so much better than boxed. I hope you love it Heidy!

Skip to Recipe